G2TT
Embrace failure, measure progress better: priorities for this year's High-level Political Forum on the SDGs  智库博客
时间:2018-07-10   作者: Elizabeth Stuart  来源:Overseas Development Institute (United Kingdom)

When nation states came together to agree the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in 2015, it may have been multilateralism’s peak.

But as ministers prepare to gather in New York next week for the High-level Political Forum (HLPF) – the annual official monitoring moment for the goals – the mood is very different. International cooperation is crumbling, threatening that sense of collective ambition.  

For this summit to succeed, we need governments to be honest about failure and rigorous in analysing progress. In preparation for next year’s head of state-level summit (there are two HLPFs next year, the September one as part of the UN General Assembly), I would like to see a new initiative to produce comprehensive country-level data on progress to ‘leave no one behind’ (LNOB) – as well as renewed engagement from high-level champions, and a commitment to bring the financing discussion together with that on policy. The political declaration from this week’s HLPF can set these things up.

Governments should acknowledge failure

The benefits of embracing failure are by now a cliché, but few high-ranking officials want to admit to challenges against the backdrop of the United Nations.

Last year’s HLPF did attempt to corral member states to give their implementation reports on multi-country panels, making discussion of pitfalls, as well as success, more likely.

But this year many member states have opted to give their reports (called Voluntary National Reviews, or VNRs) standing alone, so there will be less opportunity for challenge, debate and genuine engagement.

Of course, VNRs are not the only format for reporting on SDG progress. Germany, among the first batch of countries to present in 2016, has this year conducted a comprehensive peer review of its sustainable development strategy, meaning its commitments, plans and outcomes have already been forensically picked over. Others should follow suit, and fully present challenges as well as high points.

We need to measure progress more rigorously

If progress is to be the sole focus of the VNRs, they’ll need to be more rigorous than in the past. Just presenting anecdotes will not allow us to get a full understanding of what is changing and what is stuck.

The latest version of our ‘leave no one behind’ index is a contribution to that rigour. It assesses the readiness of 86 countries (the ones presenting their reviews at the HLPF this year, and those who did so last year) to deliver on the key SDG commitment to reach the left-behind first, looking at data, policy and finance.

It shows there has been some progress since last year, with a quarter of countries upping their readiness score. Most of that improvement has been in data, reflecting an increase in the number of countries where household surveys have been conducted in the last three years.

But it also shows that while a handful of countries have aligned their policies and budgets to what’s needed to support the poorest and most marginalised, this was offset by a similar number where alignment had deteriorated. And in more than half of the countries assessed, climate adaptation plans fail to target the most vulnerable. This should worry delegates at the Forum, whose theme is resilience.

Ministers meeting in New York should commit to producing more rigorous data on progress to 'leave no one behind' and reinvigorate ambition around the SDGs.

除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。