全球智库信息集成服务系统

Investigations and Resolutions Division (IRD) struggles with a complaint case backlog.

• Interviews and discussions with IRD personnel and military service personnel involved with the Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) process revealed concerns that a sharp increase in the number of cases received by IRD was contributing to difficulties in processing EEO complaint cases in a timely manner.

Management may be unwilling to participate in alternative dispute resolution (ADR).

• Several of our interviewees spoke highly of ADR as a way to resolve complaints in a timely manner. However, they also told us that one obstacle to its increased use is that some complainants and managers within DoD components resist its use.

Incomplete case files and confusion about necessary documentation waste time at intake.

• It takes time to obtain the needed data and documentation for incomplete EEO complaint cases submitted to IRD with requests for investigation. Interviewees also noted confusion regarding what to submit with a particular case, and our analysis of administrative databases showed that cases spent a lengthy period of time with IRD intake. The IRD provides a list of required and recommended materials on its website, but EEO personnel within the military services access the IRD site and use these document lists with variability.

Inexperienced and/or poorly trained IRD intake personnel slow the process.

• The personnel in IRD and the military services that we interviewed expressed concerns about the qualifications of IRD intake personnel.

The Department of Defense (DoD) employs hundreds of thousands of full-time civilian employees, and federal laws and executive orders stipulate that it is illegal to discriminate against these persons on the basis of several protected categories, including race, color, religion, sex, age, national origin, and disability. The Offices of Diversity Management and Equal Opportunity (ODMEO) and Civilian Personnel Policy (CPP) aim to ensure that DoD abides by these laws and orders, thereby allowing DoD civilian employees to work in an environment that is free from discrimination.

If a DoD civilian employee perceives that he or she has been discriminated against, the employee can contact the local Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) office to discuss the discrimination experience(s). If the complaint cannot be immediately resolved, the individual may subsequently file a formal EEO complaint with the local EEO office. Once a person files a formal EEO complaint, federal regulations stipulate that, barring specific circumstances, the complaint should be processed within 180 days. This 180-day time period encompasses the time of formal filing to the time an EEO office mails the report of investigation (ROI) for the complaint to the complainant.Since at least 2005, 38 percent to 53 percent of EEO complaints filed each year in DoD have not been processed within this regulated 180-day time frame. This report aims to provide information that will assist DoD in addressing this lag of formal EEO complaints.

• Chapter One

  Introduction

• Chapter Two

  Equal Employment Opportunity Discrimination Complaint Processing Within the Department of Defense and the Military Services

• Chapter Three

  Department of Defense's Lean Six Sigma Evaluation of Discrimination Complaint Processing

• Chapter Four

  Timeliness and Completeness in Department of Defense Complaint Processing

• Chapter Five

  Perceptions of and Potential Avenues for Improving Timeliness of EEO Complaint Processing in IRD

• Chapter Six

  Perceptions of and Potential Avenues for Improving Timeliness of EEO Complaint Processing in the Military Services

• Chapter Seven

  Randomized Control Trial Design to Assess Checklist Implementation

• Chapter Eight

  Conclusion and Recommendations for Formal EEO Complaint Processing in DoD