G2TT
来源类型Discussion paper
规范类型论文
来源IDDP10011
DP10011 The Illusion of School Choice: Empirical Evidence from Barcelona
maia guell; Caterina Calsamiglia
发表日期2014-06-01
出版年2014
语种英语
摘要School choice aims to improve (1) the matching between children and schools and (2) students? educational outcomes. Yet, the concern is that disadvantaged families are less able to exercise choice, which raises (3) equity concerns. The Boston mechanism (BM) is a procedure that is widely used around the world to resolve overdemands for particular schools by defining a set of priority points based on neighborhood and socioeconomic characteristics. The mechanism design literature has shown that under the BM, parents may not have incentives to provide their true preferences, thereby establishing a trade-off between preferences and perceived safety. However, the set of possible Nash equilibria arising from the BM is large and has varying properties, and what will actually happen is an empirical question. We exploit an unexpected change in the definition of neighborhood in Barcelona, which provides an exogenous change in the set of schools perceived as safe and allows us to separate housing and schooling decisions to assess the importance of this trade-off in the data. We find that safety carries a large weight in family choice. The huge majority of parents opt for schools for which they have the highest priority?the neighborhood schools?excluding other preferred schools. Similar to the previous literature, we also find that some parents seem naive, but using school registry data, we find that a significant fraction of them have the outside option of private schools, which allows them to take higher risks to access the best public schools. At the other extreme, some of the naive are not matched to any of the schools they applied for. Our results suggest that when allowing school choice under the BM with priorities: (1) the gains in terms of matching seem limited, because the equilibrium allocation is not very different from a neighborhood-based assignment, (2) estimating the effect of choice on outcomes by implementing such a mechanism may lead to a lower bound on the potential effects of having choice, and (3) important inequalities emerge beyond parents? naivete found in the literature.
主题Labour Economics
关键词Boston mechanism Priorities School choice
URLhttps://cepr.org/publications/dp10011
来源智库Centre for Economic Policy Research (United Kingdom)
资源类型智库出版物
条目标识符http://119.78.100.153/handle/2XGU8XDN/538840
推荐引用方式
GB/T 7714
maia guell,Caterina Calsamiglia. DP10011 The Illusion of School Choice: Empirical Evidence from Barcelona. 2014.
条目包含的文件
条目无相关文件。
个性服务
推荐该条目
保存到收藏夹
导出为Endnote文件
谷歌学术
谷歌学术中相似的文章
[maia guell]的文章
[Caterina Calsamiglia]的文章
百度学术
百度学术中相似的文章
[maia guell]的文章
[Caterina Calsamiglia]的文章
必应学术
必应学术中相似的文章
[maia guell]的文章
[Caterina Calsamiglia]的文章
相关权益政策
暂无数据
收藏/分享

除非特别说明,本系统中所有内容都受版权保护,并保留所有权利。